What this means in plain English
Medigap is a private policy that helps pay costs Original Medicare doesn't cover, such as coinsurance and deductibles. It doesn't work with Medicare Advantage and doesn't cover prescriptions, so most people pair it with a Part D plan (Medicare.gov). An agent can't change a plan's benefits. But an agent can change which company you buy from and whether you apply at the right time.
What to look for in Medicare supplement agents
Check the agent's license first on your state insurance department's website. Then ask how many companies they can quote for your plan letter and ZIP code. A good agent asks about your doctors and travel before quoting a price. They should also tell you if a company has a history of steep rate increases. Ask who helps you after the sale.
Top options compared
An independent agent quotes several insurers and can stay with you over time. A captive agent shows only one company's price. A call center may compare carriers, but you rarely reach the same person twice. Your State Health Insurance Assistance Program offers free counseling but doesn't sell policies (Medicare.gov). Buying direct works if you already know which company you want.
How to choose the right Medicare supplement agents
Get quotes for the same plan letter from at least two companies, and ask the agent why one costs less. If you're past your open enrollment window, ask about health questions, since a company may deny you or charge more (Medicare.gov). Plan availability and prices vary by location. Then decide if you want one call or ongoing help.
Two examples to check your timing and price
For example, if you're already 65 and your Part B starts July 1, your Medigap Open Enrollment Period runs July through December (Medicare.gov). A married couple turning 65 in different years each gets their own window and needs their own policy (Medicare.gov). And a Plan G from one company, compared with a Plan G from another, has the same basic benefits (Medicare.gov). So ask the agent to explain the price gap and each company's rate history.
What to do next
Start today by finding your Part B start date and counting six months forward. Then list your doctors and prescriptions. Call or text 888-333-5853 or schedule a free meeting with a licensed Medicare Store agent. Meet in Las Vegas, Reno, Phoenix, Albuquerque, McAllen or Laredo, ask for a house call, or talk by phone from any state. Agents check in six times your first year and twice a year after that. This page is general information, so confirm the details with a licensed agent before you enroll.
